Unfortunately. Today is the day the FCC is going to vote on Net Neutrality. According to several different news reports, it seems as though Commissioner Genachowski has got enough votes to be able to move forward with what seems to be no more than your basic governmental power grab. This one doesn’t even make sense, since it will be incredibly hard to enforce, and even harder to prove and prosecute offenders.
If you are wondering what Net Neutrality is, there are plenty of places on the Web to tell you, but in a nutshell, the FCC wants to be able to enforce certain rules. For example, the FCC wants to make sure that ISPs and Search Engines are providing only the information requested, that they are not stacking the results in favor of one cause or issue or marketer over another. I think this will be very difficult to enforce, I mean, whose going to sit around all day running queries to see if this ISP or that, or SE or other, appears to be slanting search results in one direction or another? Our massive, incredibly over sized government really doesn’t need to grow in this direction. The Web tends to maintain fairly well without the interference of the government. Nothing has really changed in this regard except that a governmental agency has decided to set its sights on the Web.
What will this mean in the long run? Nothing good, if you ask me. It’s going to make a mess of some things, as further regulation always does. It’ll tie the hands of a lot of folks, making it harder to earn money on the Web, and give everyone else involved in Web efforts something to complain about, and attempt to work around, and spend money to avoid. The end result will be that everything will get more expensive as a result. It’ll create a choke hold on Web based business, and give the government control over the Web like it’s never had before. Over regulation always means an economic loss. Yeah, now sounds like the perfect time for that – let’s create more economic loss.
Republican Robert M. McDowell, criticized Genachowski’s proposal in a Wall Street Journal column on Sunday.
“Nothing is broken that needs fixing … ” he wrote. “Analysts and broadband companies of all sizes have told the FCC that new rules are likely to have the perverse effect of inhibiting capital investment, deterring innovation, raising operating costs and ultimately increasing consumer prices.”
A few Dems are harping about free speech and the like, leaving me to wonder what in the world they think is happening on the Web right now. If we don’t have free speech on the Web as of now, I don’t know what you’d call it. We can now say nearly anything to anyone, anywhere in the world, anytime we want. We can find nearly any bit of information we need to make decisions large and small. We can buy anything we want. We can view nearly anything you can think of. Net Neutrality is the first foothold in the climb towards content control over the Web. Enjoy your freedom of speech while it lasts you may very well loose it soon.
Content control is just what it sounds like. The government will somehow try to make sure that for every opinion that is presented on the Web, the user is provided with the opposing view. How exactly is this possible? How in the world do they think they can enforce it? Fines when they find instances of it, surely. Sound like a Web tax to anyone else? Raise your hand if you see lots of dollar signs in this whole deal.
If this thing passes today, and I am pretty sure it will, it has to be voted on by Congress (because no one has even given the FCC the authority to do this – the Obama Administration just decided they could, so they are). That means there is one more chance this thing can be shot down. It won’t go for a vote in Congress until the new House and Senate are in session in the new year. Please make your voices heard on this one. This is a power grab by this government. They want to govern every aspect of our lives. The Web was built to provide free access to information, not regulated, government approved access. What is this? Iran? We don’t need to be regulated. We need the freedom to run our businesses, whether Web based or not, nearly every business is impacted in some way by the Web, even if it is only through local map searches. Let the Web alone – go regulate something else, FCC. I can’t imagine you are lacking anything needing a good dose of government regulation. Go run your car companies, leave the Web alone!
More info-
CNN
FoxNews